A Roof Leak, and a New Metal Roof For the Homestead

It’s amazing how things work out sometimes.

Notice the tarp and tires thrown up on our roof? Yeah. There’s a story here.

It all began when my husband noticed the paint splitting along the crown molding in my daughter’s bedroom.

We’d had a good two weeks of nothing but constant rain, so when my husband pointed the damaged trim out to me we both wondered if the roof could be leaking. We were concerned, but too busy at that moment to do any more investigating, so we put it in the back of our minds and went on with our day.

The next evening I remembered the spot when I was putting my daughter to bed. I grabbed a chair and climbed up to get a closer look at what might be causing the paint to crack. Maybe the house had just been settling and the trim had shifted, I thought.

I reached up to see if there was any moisture where the ceiling met the crown molding, and as I pushed on the popcorn surface my finger went right through the drywall. Water immediately began dripping in through through the new hole.


I ran to get a bowl to place under the leak to catch the rainwater. It was pouring outside with no end in sight. Seven year old Xia mused, “It’s like in that movie Charlie and The Chocolate Factory!” Charlie’s family was so poor that the shack they lived in was covered with holes in the roof, and when it rained they placed pots and buckets everywhere to catch the water.

Jerry and I knew our roof needed to be replaced soon. We were hoping we had one more year to save up for the large expense, but it seemed we were out of time. I felt thankful that we had enough money in savings to cover the project, but it saddened me greatly that every dime we’d worked so hard to save was just about to be drained down to nothing again. I really didn’t want to lose it!

We needed to get up on the roof to cover the leak, but with so much rain coming down it was too dangerous to climb up there. The rain didn’t stop, the storms in our area actually intensified.

Two days later we were under a tornado warning.

Fortunately we were at my grandfather’s house when the news alerts starting streaming across every channel on the television. He lives a county over from us, so we were out of danger from the storm. Our house, however, was right in the middle of the take-shelter zone.

We all crowded around the screen anxiously tracking the storm. Funnel clouds were spotted. Then one touched down. Was it near our home? There were so many calls coming into the station nobody was clear yet as to where the damage was.

After a tense 30 minutes the storm had passed. We were eager to get home to see what the damage was like. Later we learned that our area was fine, though an EF2 had touched down not far from home and had blown the roof off the elementary school and flipped a couple trailers. Fortunately for us, we didn’t even have trees down across our property. I was secretly disappointed that our roof hadn’t blown off so that insurance would buy us a new one.

The following evening we were home again when the next round of storms blew in. This time it was hail. It came just as we were tucking the kids into bed. When we opened the back door to see what was happening the sound of the balls of ice landing on the metal roof over the porch was absolutely deafening. We stood there covering our ears, gaping at the hail bouncing off our truck parked in the driveway.

We still hadn’t had a dry moment to put a tarp on the roof to cover the leak. Water dripped at a steady pace into the bowl on my daughter’s bedroom floor.

We put a call out to a friend of ours who does roofing to get a quote on installing a new roof. We really, REALLY wanted to go with metal for rain catchment purposes. Although there’s still a big debate out there about which type of roofing material is safest for collecting rain water, it seems to be agreed across the board that asphalt shingles are out.

Meanwhile, as we were waiting to hear back from our friend, I was bemoaning our situation to my dad when he suggested that we call our insurance company to file a claim. I argued, “But the roof is so old already. It’s like 18 years old.”

“It doesn’t matter,” he affirmed. “Call them and tell them there’s possible hail damage. They’ll come out and take a look.”

Surely they wouldn’t do anything to help us. But what if….?

I followed my dad’s advice and called my insurance company. They’d been flooded with calls for tornado and hail damage, and had had to call in agents from several hours away to come in as reinforcements. We scheduled for somebody to come out the following week to check out our roof. I also got an appointment to get our truck looked at.

Finally the rain let up enough that my husband was able to get up on the roof and cover it with a tarp to prevent more water from coming in. I was becoming increasingly concerned about mold. I know how dangerous black mold can be. Would we have to tear out the ceiling, the walls, and the insulation to repair the damage?

In the next few days I prayed a lot that our insurance would help with the damage.

The day soon arrived when the insurance agent came to our home. He had to call me several times to navigate his way in since GPS won’t get you exactly to our house. When he finally made it to our house he commented that whoever lives up a driveway like that must be interesting people. He looked around us, trees surrounding in all directions. “You put your house in the middle of nowhere!”

He was a middle aged guy. Talkative and friendly. I felt comfortable inviting him into my home to look at the damage even though I was home alone with the kids.

We went into my daughter’s bedroom and he examined the hole in the ceiling along with some damage to the drywall along the seam of the wall below the leak. He assured me that I needn’t be worried about mold because our air conditioner unit acts as a dehumidifier and will suck any moisture in the walls out and will prevent mold building up. This was something I had never considered as we’ve striven to go off grid. If we’d turned the A/C completely off we would very likely have a real problem with mold, especially in our humid climate.

Next we went outside. He leaned a ladder against the roof and climbed up. My ten year old son, Titus, scrambled up after him offering to help. This surprised the insurance man, and he exclaimed, “As long as your mother doesn’t mind!” The slope on our roof is super mellow… practically flat. Ty’s been up there plenty of times to help his Daddy with something, so of course I didn’t mind. He was wielding his hammer and tool belt eager to offer his services.

The man asked if I would come around the front of the house so that he could point to something on the roof. I began climbing up the ladder instead. “You don’t mind if I come up too, do you?” I asked.

“Mom’s coming up, too!” the man exclaimed. “This is the first time I’ve ever had a client ask to climb on the roof with me,” he added in disbelief. I laughed and told him I figured it would be easier for him to show me what the problem was if I was up there with him.

He walked me around and pointed to areas on the asphalt shingles where the grit had worn off. It could have been hail damage from this storm or previous ones, it was hard to tell. He walked me to the edge of the roof right over my daughter’s window and pointed to the problem. “See that shingle there? The nail has come up. That’s what’s causing your leak.” And he used my son’s little hammer to bang the nail back down into place.

We chatted a lot up on that hot roof. I could feel my shoulders burning as the sun beat down on us, but we were having such a nice conversation. He loved what we are doing on the land. He even took pictures of our gardens from the rooftop saying that he’d love to build raised beds in his yard.

As we talked he asked me if we’d thought about installing a metal roof. He went on about the benefits of using metal. I told him that my husband and I have been wanting metal for years for water catchment. We just weren’t sure if we could afford it. The gentleman was also a general contractor so he had a lot of advice to offer on installation of metal roofing.

After a thorough examination he announced that he’d be writing us a check to replace our whole roof. I could hardly believe my ears. More than that though, he was also giving us an allowance for the interior ceiling and wall damage, including repainting, and for removing and replacing our solar panels. The amount he was able to give us was enough to replace our shingles with new metal roofing.

As I stood holding the check in my hands, I was overcome with gratitude. Our prayers had been answered. I whispered words of thanks to the Father, and then called my husband with the incredible news.

Our roof is being installed today. Our good friend who does roofing is allowing my husband to help him install the metal panels, saving us over $2000 in labor charges. I can’t wait to see how it looks when it’s all done.

Click here for before and after photos!


23 thoughts on “A Roof Leak, and a New Metal Roof For the Homestead”

  1. You’re gonna love that metal roof.We had one put on last year.the house is so much cooler and we don’t have to worry about leaks! We had to pay full price for ours so y’all got so blessed!

  2. I’m amazed that the adjuster allowed you both on the roof. Imagine if one of you had fallen off and made another claim on the very policy for which he was there. He’d probably have lost his job!
    Congratulations on the new roof, you will love it. And what a blessing from God to cover the cost. It should last for at least 50 years.

  3. Delighted to hear it worked out!

    I recommend checking with your home owner’s insurance to see how many claims you can make before they drop you coverage. In some areas, it can be two claims, so when you file the second time, they may pay, but they’ll drop you and that makes it hard to get another company to cover you. It can happen with something as small as making two damage claims for a shed next to the house. You also have to be careful about the premium increases.

  4. That is amazing, congratulations Kendra! The Lord was certainly listening! We live in north central Texas where hail storms are a constant issue every spring, so I am very familiar with roof damage due to hail. If you have a hailstorm, it is ALWAYS worth calling insurance to take a look, even if your roof is old or you think it didn’t get any damage. Most times (at least here) they will opt to just replace the roof. I am so glad things worked out.

    • We’ve had hail here so many times in the eight years we’ve been on the land. It never occurred to me that it might damage my roof. Live and learn! 🙂

  5. God Almighty can always take care of the details better than we can imagine. I am happy for you and your wonderfull little family, that you recognize and acknowledge the Source of those awesome blessings. And, it sounds like the insurance adjustor was a pleasantly willing servant sent to help you. Thank you for sharing, Sweetie!

  6. That is awesome! I always had assumed that insurance is only for catastrophes – like my house pretty much has to be uninhabitable before we could file a claim. But no! When we bought our house it came with a one-year warranty on all of the appliances that were left. I assumed that was only if they died within that year. But my agent specifically told us to call in a claim for ANYTHING amiss – even funny noises. I did and we got a new washer, fridge, and dishwasher -just for calling in and inquiring.

    Now I know – it never hurts to ask your insurance agent to at least have a look!

    • Wow!! I would have never guessed they’d cover so much. Honestly I thought the insurance agent would come out and be like, “Yeah right. This roof is ancient.” I was so grateful to my dad for suggesting I call them!

  7. My heart sings for you. What a beautiful synchronicity that the universe pulls for you. You must be very good peoples.


Leave a Comment